11-26-2025, 02:51 AM
Button Accuracy (Recommended for Most Players)
A timing meter appears when throwing. Hit the green section for MLB The Show 25 Stubs perfect accuracy.
Advantages:
Consistent
Easy to learn
Reduces random wild throws
Best For:
All skill levels
Analog Throwing (For Advanced Players)
Uses the right stick to aim your throws. More control, but more risk.
Advantages:
Works incredibly well for players with strong mechanics
Allows for precise throws to cutoffs or bases
Best For:
Experienced players who want full control
Button Throwing (Classic)
No meter—accuracy is based on attributes.
Advantages:
Simple and fast
Fewer input mistakes
Best For:
Beginners or RTTS players leveling up defensive stats
Pro Tip:
You can mix styles. Many players use Button Accuracy for infield and Analog for outfield throws.
Tip #3: Don’t Pre-Load Throws Too Early
Pre-loading too early often triggers rushed animations, increasing the odds of wild throws or muffed pickups.
Correct Timing:
Fielding → Secure Ball → THEN Aim Throw
Count “one-half second” after securing the ball on tricky plays
Avoid holding the throw button during charging animations
This eliminates 70% of infield errors instantly.
Tip #4: Use Manual Throw Cancels to Avoid Bad Decisions
In MLB The Show 25, tapping R2 allows you to cancel a throw mid-animation.
Use Throw Cancels When:
The runner is already safe
You accidentally aim at the wrong base
A fielder double-clutches the ball
The throwing lane becomes blocked
Throw cancels save countless runs and prevent long overthrows that lead to extra bases.
Tip #5: Set Proper Defensive Positioning Before Every Batter
One of the biggest mistakes players make is relying on default positioning. You should adjust based on:
Pull vs. Opposite Field tendencies
Speed of the batter
Pitch type you’re throwing
Game situation (shift, double play depth, corners in)
Best Usage:
Shift Left/Right: Use Sparingly, mainly vs. heavy pull hitters
Double Play Depth: Use when a runner is on first
Corners In: Use when expecting a bunt
Outfield Depth: Adjust vs. power hitters or contact hitters
Proper positioning reduces the distance fielders travel → fewer late jumps, slower animations, and dropped balls.
Tip #6: Use the Right Players at Key Defensive Spots
Some positions cannot afford weak defenders:
Critical Defense Positions:
Shortstop
Center Field
Catcher
Third Base
Positions You Can “Hide” Weak Defense:
First Base
Left Field (to a degree)
If you want fewer errors, aim for:
Gold defense (80+) at SS and CF
Silver or Gold at 3B, 2B, and RF
Good Arm Strength behind the plate (80+)
Defense-first players are often cheap in Diamond Dynasty—making them some of the best budget pickups.
Tip #7: Make Smarter Outfield Routes
The outfield is where the biggest defensive mistakes happen, often because players take the wrong first step.
Best Practices for Outfielding:
Don’t sprint immediately—wait for the ball’s trajectory
Use small corrective movements instead of MLB The Show 25 Stubs for sale over-correcting
Learn to read the new MLB The Show 25 ball flight physics
Hold down R2 for ball location if you lose track
Practice “two-step hesitation” vs liners to avoid overruns
Small adjustments drastically improve catch consistency.
Tip #8: Choose Strong Defensive Substitutes Late in Games
Late-game defense wins tight matchups. Keep a few bench players specifically for defense.
Ideal Defensive Subs:
A high-speed CF/OF
A strong-fielding SS/2B
A catcher with 85+ Arm Strength
Insert them after the 7th inning to eliminate late errors.
Tip #9: Use High-Fielding First Basemen to Save Bad Throws
First basemen with great Fielding and Reaction dramatically reduce throwing errors from infielders.
Look for Attributes:
75+ Fielding
70+ Reaction
Good Stretching Animations (certain players have better motion capture)
This single upgrade can reduce throwing errors by 30–40%.
Tip #10: Practice in Custom Training Mode
Fielding is a skill. The best way to improve is by using custom training:
Practice Drills:
Hard grounders at SS
Charging slow rollers
Outfield fly ball routes
High-pressure throwing meter timing
Double-play feeds and throws
Ten minutes of practice per day improves timing and instincts dramatically.
Final Thoughts: Clean Defense Wins Games
Mastering the defensive meta in MLB The Show 25 takes time, but the payoff is massive. Clean, consistent defense:
Reduces critical errors
Extends your pitchers’ effectiveness
Saves dozens of runs per Ranked Season
Allows you to win low-scoring, competitive matchups
If you build a strong defensive core, master timing windows, and stay disciplined with positioning, you’ll immediately notice fewer errors and more clean innings.
A timing meter appears when throwing. Hit the green section for MLB The Show 25 Stubs perfect accuracy.
Advantages:
Consistent
Easy to learn
Reduces random wild throws
Best For:
All skill levels
Analog Throwing (For Advanced Players)
Uses the right stick to aim your throws. More control, but more risk.
Advantages:
Works incredibly well for players with strong mechanics
Allows for precise throws to cutoffs or bases
Best For:
Experienced players who want full control
Button Throwing (Classic)
No meter—accuracy is based on attributes.
Advantages:
Simple and fast
Fewer input mistakes
Best For:
Beginners or RTTS players leveling up defensive stats
Pro Tip:
You can mix styles. Many players use Button Accuracy for infield and Analog for outfield throws.
Tip #3: Don’t Pre-Load Throws Too Early
Pre-loading too early often triggers rushed animations, increasing the odds of wild throws or muffed pickups.
Correct Timing:
Fielding → Secure Ball → THEN Aim Throw
Count “one-half second” after securing the ball on tricky plays
Avoid holding the throw button during charging animations
This eliminates 70% of infield errors instantly.
Tip #4: Use Manual Throw Cancels to Avoid Bad Decisions
In MLB The Show 25, tapping R2 allows you to cancel a throw mid-animation.
Use Throw Cancels When:
The runner is already safe
You accidentally aim at the wrong base
A fielder double-clutches the ball
The throwing lane becomes blocked
Throw cancels save countless runs and prevent long overthrows that lead to extra bases.
Tip #5: Set Proper Defensive Positioning Before Every Batter
One of the biggest mistakes players make is relying on default positioning. You should adjust based on:
Pull vs. Opposite Field tendencies
Speed of the batter
Pitch type you’re throwing
Game situation (shift, double play depth, corners in)
Best Usage:
Shift Left/Right: Use Sparingly, mainly vs. heavy pull hitters
Double Play Depth: Use when a runner is on first
Corners In: Use when expecting a bunt
Outfield Depth: Adjust vs. power hitters or contact hitters
Proper positioning reduces the distance fielders travel → fewer late jumps, slower animations, and dropped balls.
Tip #6: Use the Right Players at Key Defensive Spots
Some positions cannot afford weak defenders:
Critical Defense Positions:
Shortstop
Center Field
Catcher
Third Base
Positions You Can “Hide” Weak Defense:
First Base
Left Field (to a degree)
If you want fewer errors, aim for:
Gold defense (80+) at SS and CF
Silver or Gold at 3B, 2B, and RF
Good Arm Strength behind the plate (80+)
Defense-first players are often cheap in Diamond Dynasty—making them some of the best budget pickups.
Tip #7: Make Smarter Outfield Routes
The outfield is where the biggest defensive mistakes happen, often because players take the wrong first step.
Best Practices for Outfielding:
Don’t sprint immediately—wait for the ball’s trajectory
Use small corrective movements instead of MLB The Show 25 Stubs for sale over-correcting
Learn to read the new MLB The Show 25 ball flight physics
Hold down R2 for ball location if you lose track
Practice “two-step hesitation” vs liners to avoid overruns
Small adjustments drastically improve catch consistency.
Tip #8: Choose Strong Defensive Substitutes Late in Games
Late-game defense wins tight matchups. Keep a few bench players specifically for defense.
Ideal Defensive Subs:
A high-speed CF/OF
A strong-fielding SS/2B
A catcher with 85+ Arm Strength
Insert them after the 7th inning to eliminate late errors.
Tip #9: Use High-Fielding First Basemen to Save Bad Throws
First basemen with great Fielding and Reaction dramatically reduce throwing errors from infielders.
Look for Attributes:
75+ Fielding
70+ Reaction
Good Stretching Animations (certain players have better motion capture)
This single upgrade can reduce throwing errors by 30–40%.
Tip #10: Practice in Custom Training Mode
Fielding is a skill. The best way to improve is by using custom training:
Practice Drills:
Hard grounders at SS
Charging slow rollers
Outfield fly ball routes
High-pressure throwing meter timing
Double-play feeds and throws
Ten minutes of practice per day improves timing and instincts dramatically.
Final Thoughts: Clean Defense Wins Games
Mastering the defensive meta in MLB The Show 25 takes time, but the payoff is massive. Clean, consistent defense:
Reduces critical errors
Extends your pitchers’ effectiveness
Saves dozens of runs per Ranked Season
Allows you to win low-scoring, competitive matchups
If you build a strong defensive core, master timing windows, and stay disciplined with positioning, you’ll immediately notice fewer errors and more clean innings.